Release Date: Sunday December 25, 2011
Genre: Drama, War
Director: Steven Spielberg
Cinematographer: Janusz Kaminski
Screenplay: Lee Hall, Richard Curtis, Michael Morpurgo (novel)
Cast: Emily Watson, David Thewlis, Peter Mullan, Niels Arestrup,
Tom Hiddleston, Jeremy Irvine, Benedict Cumberbatch, Toby Kebbell
by Peter Frieday January 24, 2012
War Horse (2011) is Steven Spielberg’s film adaptation of Michael Morpurgo’s 1982 children’s book of the same name. The book has also been adapted into a live stage production and has had successful runs in England and Broadway. Although it is based on a children’s book, this film is not for kids under thirteen. There are scenes of soldiers being killed and an execution. That’s disappointing because War Horse should not be limited to an older audience. Everyone including younger kids should be reminded of the sacrifices made for our freedom and democracy.
Albert Narracott ( Jeremy Irvine) the son of an English farmer Ted Narracott ( Peter Mullan) trains and develops a friendship with a beautiful thoroughbred horse whom he names Joey. Albert’s mother is Rose Narracot ( Emily Watson ) who spends her days toiling away on the farm but did not approve of spending all of their money on buying Joey at a horse auction. Albert promises to train and care for the horse and does just that. Things change when in 1914 WWI starts and horses are in huge demand. Ted decides to sell Joey to the British army because he needs the money to pay his landlord Lyons (David Thewlis). Time goes by and eventually Albert enlists in the war himself in search of his beloved horse.
The British army was sent to France and the Western Front during WWI (1914 – 1918). The Western Front was the name the German army gave to a series of trenches that ran over 400 miles from the Belgian coast to the Swiss border. The German objective was to advance and capture Paris. Fierce trench warfare took place during the war and thousands of lives were lost. War Horse depicts trench conditions and trench fighting. The film shows us how important horses were in the fighting despite the fact that the Germans fought back with machine gun fire and artillery that killed many defenseless horses. The horses allowed allied soldiers to maneuver around and create surprise attacks against the German army. There is an especially poignant and impressive scene in War Horse where the British army is lined up on their horses with swords drawn. They then ambush a German base camp. That intense battle scene demonstrated the sacrifices made by military horses. Working in terrible conditions, many of these horses also supplied troops with food, water and transported ammunition. Not only did thousands of horses die from enemy fire but many more died from starvation, injury or exhaustion. The war was cruel to these majestic animals. Thousands and thousands of horses suffered and died during WWI. Many a soldier survived in the war zone with the help of their horse. In the trivia department, it was interesting to learn that all the horses had been trained for several weeks prior to filming so that they could perform the various action scenes. If you are an animal lover such as myself, then you will be happy to know that many of the horses seen killed in battle were actually fake prop horses and the heavy artillery the horses were seen pulling were also light imitation props according to the American Humane Society.
I appreciated and enjoyed the cinematography in this film. Cinematographer Janusz Kaminski did great work with his photography of Joey galloping outside in the fields and the close up shots of our protagonist horse’s head. I love horses so this was an easy movie for me to watch but the few but important imperfections in the film tainted the experience for me. Firstly, there is a scene in the movie that will require a suspension of disbelief. That is when Joey is caught in barbed wire and both a British and German soldier meet inside No Mans Land at the trenches to try to save Joey. That scene doesn’t work and lasted too long. Would that happen in a real war ? It’s hard to fathom the idea. The silence and cooperation between the two opposing soldiers over a horse seemed surreal. Secondly, Spielberg needed to make better cautionary choices with this production. Why wasn’t it made to be compatible with younger kids ? Some politeness mixed in with the emotion of war is possible. Was it really necessary for Spielberg to have that scene showing the firing squad execution of the two young brothers ? I don’t believe so. That is the moment I lost my respect. I wanted to and was hoping to like War Horse but I feel dispassionate about it.

